The Jobcentre's powers to compel claimants to do things (useless or not) have limits but they have a nice little trick to get around the regulations.
Let's say you want to put on an information session for 50 jobseekers. Maybe you believe it's a good and useful session and compelling attendance your chosen group of claimants is the right thing to do. Or, more cynically, you know it's a great way to frustrate and inconvenience them into closing their claim. No problem - it works either way!
There's no official way to compel attendance at a Group Information Session - the guidances says:
5. There is no mandatory requirement for claimants to attend a Group
Information Session and as such DMA action does not apply. If a claimant
does not attend their Group Information Session their claim must not be
closed. (Source)
So what a lot of Jobcentres are doing is to issue a letter inviting claimants to the session but which goes on to say that afterwards they'll have an interview with an advisor and threatens that failure to attend the interview could result in loss of JSA. This is "correct" because the The Jobseeker’s Allowance Regulations say:
23. A claimant shall participate in an interview in such manner, time and place
as an employment officer may specify by a notification which is given or sent to the
claimant and which may be in writing, by telephone or by electronic means
What many jobseekers have found (me included) is that there is in fact no interview - just the session which may or may not be useful - and certainly wasn't in my case.
It's time it stopped
Although I'm now employed, I used to be Jobcentre "stock". The experience was sometimes so unpleasant, I became radicalised. However, I acknowledge that some of the staff are wonderful. In this blog, I pick up on apparent malpractice and try to find evidence either way.
One technique is to ask the DWP to send me guidance designed to prevent the malpractice and also any research they’ve done to detect it.
Showing posts with label Techniques. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Techniques. Show all posts
13 November 2015
21 July 2015
The efficacy of neuro-linguistic programming by the DWP
Nice bit of work here by Frank Zola, a veritable thorn in the side of the DWP.
The DWP looked to be embracing "neuro-linguistic programming" and forcing it on welfare claimants. It's controversial but does NLP work - or more to the point, does the DWP have evidence that it works?
The answer according to the results of Mr. Zola's FOI request is "DWP does not hold any recorded information in relation to your requests around Neuro-Linguistic Programming (NLP)"
I.E. the DWP doesn't know. A nice example of this technique
The DWP looked to be embracing "neuro-linguistic programming" and forcing it on welfare claimants. It's controversial but does NLP work - or more to the point, does the DWP have evidence that it works?
The answer according to the results of Mr. Zola's FOI request is "DWP does not hold any recorded information in relation to your requests around Neuro-Linguistic Programming (NLP)"
I.E. the DWP doesn't know. A nice example of this technique
10 February 2015
Sanctions used as a Last Resort
DWP people are often quoted as saying that sanctions are used as a "Last Resort" EG:
"Sanctions are applied as a last resort when claimants fail to do enough to find work, fail to attend appointments or have turned down job offers..." (1)
However, there are many claims that they as used as a first resort (2)
So what's the truth? We may soon find out via an FOI request "Number of people sanctioned for missing just one JSA appointment". This doesn't simply ask the obvious question, it also asks:
"If DWP don’t have this number, then how can Iain Duncan Smith possibly know, or be believed, that JSA benefit sanctions for failure to attend an adviser interview were only applied as a last resort?"
Strictly speaking, DWP can decline to answer that by arguing that it isn't "recorded information" but I note with approval the use of a technique I've blogged about before - ask for recorded information that should exist, force an admission that it doesn't exist and then comment adversely.
Another pertinent FOI request is about "Sanctions comprehensive monitoring regime" which refers to this government statement:
"Sanctions are used as a last resort and the DWP has put in place a comprehensive monitoring regime to ensure that sanctions are always and only applied where appropriate to do so."
Finally, a request that asks rather directly for the evidence relied on for these statements that sanctions are used as a "last resort"
These requests are at various stages - stay tuned for updates
"Sanctions are applied as a last resort when claimants fail to do enough to find work, fail to attend appointments or have turned down job offers..." (1)
However, there are many claims that they as used as a first resort (2)
So what's the truth? We may soon find out via an FOI request "Number of people sanctioned for missing just one JSA appointment". This doesn't simply ask the obvious question, it also asks:
"If DWP don’t have this number, then how can Iain Duncan Smith possibly know, or be believed, that JSA benefit sanctions for failure to attend an adviser interview were only applied as a last resort?"
Strictly speaking, DWP can decline to answer that by arguing that it isn't "recorded information" but I note with approval the use of a technique I've blogged about before - ask for recorded information that should exist, force an admission that it doesn't exist and then comment adversely.
Another pertinent FOI request is about "Sanctions comprehensive monitoring regime" which refers to this government statement:
"Sanctions are used as a last resort and the DWP has put in place a comprehensive monitoring regime to ensure that sanctions are always and only applied where appropriate to do so."
Finally, a request that asks rather directly for the evidence relied on for these statements that sanctions are used as a "last resort"
These requests are at various stages - stay tuned for updates
2 February 2015
DWP -STILL- have no idea if Workfare costs jobs or not
It's often alleged by Boycott Workfare and others that Workfare costs jobs. Why would employers recruit paid workers when they can get slaves from the Jobcentre for nothing? The DWP, aware of this allegation counter it by having "strict" guidelines that paid jobs must not be displaced. Nearly a year ago I took to wondering if they did any research, auditing, etc. to make sure the guidelines were kept to. The answer was they didn't.
Recently I asked essentially the same question again in hopes that the DWP would have now done some work on it. After a tussle it emerged that they still have no idea if Workfare costs jobs or not
``Although there are strict guidelines in place that providers must follow when sourcing appropriate placements I can confirm that we do not hold the information you requested for MWA and CWP placements``
This is very disappointing. As I pointed out a couple of weeks ago, the Irish equivalent of the DWP have commissioned some proper research and even chucked some "employers" off their scheme for displacing jobs.
The other disappointing aspect of this response is the determination of the DWP to coyly avoid admitting that they'd put no effort into this important matter. Their initial response gives lots of information about guidelines, the benevolent intent of schemes, how they are delivered, the contracted providers and meetings. What it does not do is provide the recorded information I requested on "all research intended to measure compliance".
I solved this by asking them to do a Review of their response and quoted the very useful Section 1(1) of the FOI Act that says they have to either provide the information or say that they don't hold it.
You may find this useful if you want to be sure that a Government does not know something you think it should. For more on this technique, see here
Recently I asked essentially the same question again in hopes that the DWP would have now done some work on it. After a tussle it emerged that they still have no idea if Workfare costs jobs or not
``Although there are strict guidelines in place that providers must follow when sourcing appropriate placements I can confirm that we do not hold the information you requested for MWA and CWP placements``
This is very disappointing. As I pointed out a couple of weeks ago, the Irish equivalent of the DWP have commissioned some proper research and even chucked some "employers" off their scheme for displacing jobs.
The other disappointing aspect of this response is the determination of the DWP to coyly avoid admitting that they'd put no effort into this important matter. Their initial response gives lots of information about guidelines, the benevolent intent of schemes, how they are delivered, the contracted providers and meetings. What it does not do is provide the recorded information I requested on "all research intended to measure compliance".
I solved this by asking them to do a Review of their response and quoted the very useful Section 1(1) of the FOI Act that says they have to either provide the information or say that they don't hold it.
You may find this useful if you want to be sure that a Government does not know something you think it should. For more on this technique, see here
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)